Re-charting of The Beatle’s Help Custom
- This topic is empty.
-
Posts
-
This is one of the major problems I have had with the official releases. The chart is inaccurate for pro guitar (most of all), guitar, bass has some strange inaccuracies and just the beginning line is a three part harmony than a 2 part.
I’m not sure if anyone has thought of re-charting this yet but it really needs some attention.
Submit a ticket in our bug tracking system.
” src=”/wp-content/uploads/invision_emoticons/default_SA_wink.gif”>Considering this was released back when c3 started and has countless downloads, I find this kind of comment interesting. Nobody else has found a problem with it but you did. And this is how you thought it was a proper way to bring it up?
Not by using the bug tracker. Or by contacting the author directly (me) or even by posting in the somewhat related Beatles thread.
Also, official c3 releases can’t be modified and shared on our forums. If there is a problem, users can go on the bug tracker and create a report for the author to go over.
Just make sure you can substantiate your claims. “It’s inaccurate” doesn’t help anyone get to a better chart.
Well, I didn’t necessarily consider it a bug so I couldn’t really decide where to put this
” src=”/wp-content/uploads/invision_emoticons/default_SA_cheeky.001.gif” />. For the inaccuracies, the arpeggios on pro guitar seem to be charted differently through out the song even though George is just playing the same thing every single time. Also the chords played on acoustic go A C#m F#m D G A played in their standard positions. The breakdown before the last chorus where its just John and his guitar, he is still playing the same chord progression as the normal verses, not an arpeggio on A. Pro bass has just a couple of notes mischarted so it isn’t such a huge deal.
Standard guitar, when George once again plays his downward arpeggios it goes 4 notes at a time descending in a RYBO GRYO GRYB kind of pattern instead of a zig zag that is just charted the same.
All My Loving is charted very well but its just this song that suffers. I’m not trying to put you down as a charter, I’m just pointing out where improvements are needed especially in the pro section.
Don’t worry, I don’t get offended by “ur chart sukz” comments. But this post is not the right way to go about it.
Pro was done by columbo777, and I can’t do anything about it. Take it up with him. For the other stuff, put it up on the bug tracker and we’ll see from there.
Alright, no problem. Didn’t mean to start anything, and we demand more Beatles
” src=”/wp-content/uploads/invision_emoticons/default_SA_wink.gif” />.Haven’t you heard? I’m retired. Or at least trying to be. There may or may not be users charting more Beatles customs, but that’s out of my control.
Ok, here I am. I am always ready to hear feedback on my PRO charts. (It’s been hard to get feedback in the past since so few play PRO.) When I get home this evening, I’ll dust off the project files on that PRO. Let me know your suggestions (in TAB format if you can) and we can discuss. Please remember that there are 3 guitar players and only 2 guitar paths and sometimes that introduces and issue that has to be addressed via ‘as played on lead/rhythm’.
Oh, I redid your “Its still rock and roll to me” pro chart. For whatever reason, the midi was complete invalid (negative values and such). I had to redo it from scratch.
Oh thank you very much for fixing it! I hope I haven’t been too much of nuisance regarding the Help custom, I just didn’t know what was up with it.
Send the Rock and Roll custom to me if you can
” src=”/wp-content/uploads/invision_emoticons/default_SA_biggrin.gif” />http://www.mediafire.com/download/ouuz6 … droll_plus
(and added to pro spreadsheet on google docs)
Now, on to HELP. You need to send me some input here. I charted it as I chart all the PRO tracks, as *I* learned to play it. So, HELP is currently a reflection of how I play it. If I am playing it wrong, that’s ok, I would love to correct it. But you descriptions are a big vague for me.
Please send or post some notes like:
Before [song part] note x02220 Should be note (or sequence of notes) 57775
Remember, I am self taught for the most part and not musically trained.
please send me the BASS corrections also, as I now have a friend learning bass and I am trying to be accurate for his sake if nothing else.
Despite the lack of input, I found and corrected 3 parts of the HELP pro guitar track. I dont play bass, so without input that remains as is… please remember that there is not a distinction between Rhythm and Lead in RB. You chart what the 5 button is doing, which can be either or both depending on the charter. In the case of HELP, I did the best I could to make it work. I did fix the 53335 that was supposed to be a D, and changed it to open (xx0232).
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.