[R3M]

This is from the same run through as Comfortably Numb. So I only have feedback from playing in game. I intended (and might another day) to look at the chart in Reaper but got a bit, disheartened…

 

Misc

– volume level is way too loud, specially compared to your other two PF songs. For reference, I had the other two at volume 18 on my system, had to go down to 14 to play this song…

 

Guitar

– intro riff is missing notes, after the RB chord, there’s a short but audible guitar note. happens more than once.

– unless there is a second guitar that’s not charted by choice, notes are missing that can be played.

– sustains without space before next note on some occasions, refer to what I said in this regard on the Comfortably Numb thread.

 

Vocals

– note tubes are too long, so notes are too close to each other

– Why are outro “whooos” and other notes not charted?

– why is the second vocal part that talks in the outro not charted?

 

Drums

– what happened to the animations? – may be missing [play] event(s).

VOLUME IS DUE TO ME BEING DUMB.

The RBN docs, if I recall, only say to chart one instrument at a time. I will fix the tubing. I considered the talking part part of the backing ambience of the song, if that makes any sense.

[R3M]

this

thanks fixing, version 2 should be out soon, along with next versions of the other songs.

– Why is the majority of the song on Harm2 and not on Harm1?

david gilmour sings the choruses, roger waters sings the verses.

[R3M]

I can’t thank you enough Nemo. I don’t like being coddled, and you really helped fix up the chart.

[R3M]

Thanks, fixing all that you said. It’s honestly a bit embarrassing, but hey, learning experience.

[R3M]

How about you tell me what’s wrong instead of nagging me to postpone? If you tell me to fix something, I will fix it

 

This is the wrong attitude to take. I already mentioned these are huge songs. They require extremely close attention to detail. It is on you to ensure the quality of your work.

If the song has too many issues that can’t be fixed on a timely fashion, you’ll have to consider postponing. I’ve yet to see one comment say “great work…nothing needs fixing!”

 

I’ll be playing through the songs tonight and will give general feedback.

I completely understand this, I just think if people leave feedback, I can get these songs released on the 16th. I was just unhappy that he was too general.

[R3M]

Alright, so here is my Guitar test:

all this

thanks, I didn’t chart all of it, and i’m fixing everything you said as we speak.

[R3M]

How about you tell me what’s wrong instead of nagging me to postpone? If you tell me to fix something, I will fix it

[R3M]

added pro and lower difficulties!

[R3M]

Guys, instead of being worried something is not up to scratch, download the file and test it. ” src=”/wp-content/uploads/invision_emoticons/default_SA_smile.gif” />

Yeah, please. I need all the feedback I can get.

[R3M]

Don’t worry, money already has its lower difficulies almost completed, and I’m working on Run Like Hell’s.

[R3M]

and there is a custom PRO chart in Rocksmith, which can be converted in EOF to RB3. (hint hint, please someone do this)

 

PC: http://www.sendspace.com/file/9q7i7b

Xbox: http://www.sendspace.com/file/l8b83j

I’ll do it, I got an hour.

[R3M]

Nyx and I played through this last night. We really want this to be a good one, which means lots of feedback, right?

 

I’ll speak to the PRO guitar. The SOLO is missing lots of notes towards the end (after the 19 note). I did not check the 5 button.

 

Drums has major problems according the Nyx, he should have details…

that’s for good reason. Doesn’t the protar only have so many frets?

And drums? I didn’t expect drums to have issues.

[R3M]

I’m going to do Four Chords by the Axis of Awesome. Google it, it’s amazing.

Does this mean I get like 40 songs added to my tag?

[R3M]

Done.

[R3M]

Thanks for the concern, and I will try my best to make the charts their best. I don’t think I need to postpone.

[Author]

Posts