[Anonymous]

Wanted to ask… Would it be possible for someone to do an alternate version of “In The Air Tonight” by using a (Live) version of the song? So that it would end properly… (I don’t like the cut-off and that keeps me from playing this song more often then I would).

 

I know that somebody else charted a (Live) version of the song, but it wasn’t as good as this chart obviously and would rather see an alternate version of this chart using the (Live) version of the song.

[Farottone]

Wanted to ask… Would it be possible for someone to do an alternate version of “In The Air Tonight” by using a (Live) version of the song? So that it would end properly… (I don’t like the cut-off and that keeps me from playing this song more often then I would).

 

To be honest, the ending is the last thing that would convince me to author another version of a song. ” src=”/wp-content/uploads/invision_emoticons/default_SA_smile.gif”> However, Phil Collins’ live performance are almost always far better than the studio versions, so I would love one day to go back and do this one too.

[Anonymous]

To be honest, the ending is the last thing that would convince me to author another version of a song. ” src=”/wp-content/uploads/invision_emoticons/default_SA_smile.gif” /> However, Phil Collins’ live performance are almost always far better than the studio versions, so I would love one day to go back and do this one too.

 

I agree. I would love to see Phil Collins live… Especially “In The Air Tonight”… So here’s to hoping for a grand Live version of that awesome song! Plus it shouldn’t be that hard since you’ve done the studio version, yes? They still follow similar notes, right?

[Farottone]

I agree. I would love to see Phil Collins live… Especially “In The Air Tonight”… So here’s to hoping for a grand Live version of that awesome song! Plus it shouldn’t be that hard since you’ve done the studio version, yes? They still follow similar notes, right?

 

Not really, having a studio version of a song probably saves no more than 10% of the total time, not even counting keys, that in some cases will probably make the song not doable by C3 standards because of improvisation and the lack of stems.

[bluesfan38]

Wanted to ask… Would it be possible for someone to do an alternate version of “In The Air Tonight” by using a (Live) version of the song? So that it would end properly… (I don’t like the cut-off and that keeps me from playing this song more often then I would).

 

To be honest, the ending is the last thing that would convince me to author another version of a song. ” src=”/wp-content/uploads/invision_emoticons/default_SA_smile.gif” /> However, Phil Collins’ live performance are almost always far better than the studio versions, so I would love one day to go back and do this one too.

Man, the farewell tour version of that is so amazing. I love throwing on hits like that and take me home. I’ll never understand why some people are so jaded about live recordings. Especially 5.1 blu – ray versions.

[Author]

Posts